Lorraine Pascale 

Supermarket staples: taste test

Economy range pizzas, digestive biscuits, fish fingers and more, tasted and rated by Lorraine Pascale
  
  

Vanilla ice cream
Vanilla ice cream. Photograph: Dave King/Getty Images Photograph: Dave King/Getty Images

Vanilla ice cream

Waitrose Essential Vanilla Soft Scoop Ice Cream
1l, £1.09
This has the best vanilla flavour out of all of them, it's also nice and creamy.
★★★

Morrisons M Savers Vanilla Ice Cream
2l, £1.15
Tastes a bit like frozen ice. There is a little hit of cream at the end, which is nice but it needs more vanilla.
★★

The Co-operative Simply Value Vanilla Ice Cream
2l, £1.05
Starts off being lovely and creamy but then the taste disappears.
★★

Marks & Spencer Simply Soft Scoop Vanilla Ice Cream
1l, £1.80
The vanilla flavouring is quite obvious and leaves a strange taste in the mouth.

Fish fingers

Marks & Spencer Simply Chunky Cod Fish Fingers
400g, £2.90
Easily the best one, has a lovely crunch to the breadcrumbs and great big pieces of fish.
★★★★

Waitrose Essential 10 Cod Fish Fingers
300g, £1.91, waitrose.com
There are lovely bits of fish in these fingers but the crumbs are too soft.
★★★

Morrisons M Savers 10 Fish Fingers
250g, 60p
These are so thin it's like they've forgotten to put the fish in, but what's there is reasonably tasty.
★★

Sainsbury's Basics 10 Breaded Fish Fingers
250g, 60p
Not nearly enough fish in these and they seem to fall apart quite easily.
★★

Digestive Biscuits

Morrisons M Savers Digestives
400g, 40p
Gorgeous. Nutty and sweet with a beautiful flavour. BEST BUY
★★★★

Waitrose Essential Digestive Biscuits
500g, 70p
Quite plain tasting but it's not too sweet, which is a good thing.
★★★

Tesco Everyday Value Digestives
400g
A lot of texture to this biscuit, possibly too much. It's also far too sweet.
★★

Sainsbury's Basics Digestive Biscuits
400g, 40p
This is even sweeter, but it has a better texture and isn't too grainy.
★★

Cheese and tomato pizza

Tesco Everyday Value Cheese & Tomato Pizza
480g, £1.50
Lovely and crispy. Can taste herbs so it's definitely the most flavoursome.
★★★

Waitrose Thin & Crispy Cheese and Tomato Pizza
250g, £2.49
I like the thinness of the base but the flavour is a bit lacking.
★★

The Co-operative Simply Value Cheese & Tomato Pizza
268g, 63p
Too much dough and not enough tomato or cheese!

Morrisons M Savers Deep Pan Cheese & Tomato Pizza
405g, £1
Way too much bread, even if it is supposed to be a deep pan. Not good at all.

Macaroni Cheese

Sainsbury's Basics Macaroni Cheese
300g, 60p
This is actually quite delicious. There is a real depth of flavour. Very good.
★★★★

Morrisons M Savers Macaroni Cheese
300g, 80p
Extra cheesy, which is good but it's also bizarrely bland. It's watery too, which isn't nice.
★★

Tesco Everyday Value Macaroni Cheese
400g, 80p
Apart from being very bland, the pasta is too thick.

Waitrose Essentials Macaroni Cheese
350g, £1.79
Incredibly tasteless, apart from the salt of which there is far too much. No taste of cheese at all.

Houmous

Waitrose Essential Houmous
200g, 95p
This one has the best texture, and probably the best flavour, but there isn't much in it.
★★★

Sainsbury's Basics Houmous
200g, 85p
This is missing the good sesame kick that you'd expect. Is a bit too sour too, but not terrible.
★★

Tesco Everyday Value Houmous Dip
300g, 98p
Incredibly sour. Also, I know it's supposed to be textured but this is far too grainy, it's not nice.

Morrisons M Savers Houmous Dip
150g, 55p
I wouldn't call this houmous!

Lorraine Pascale's Fast, Fresh and Easy Food (RRP £20) is available for £16 with free UK p&p fromthe Guardian Bookshop

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*